Gotta have Upvotes and Downvotes

Have recommendations for this forum? Post here!
Post Reply
User avatar
DodoSwarm
Newcomer
Posts: 3
Registered for: 1 month

Gotta have Upvotes and Downvotes

Post by DodoSwarm »

if this forum substitute takes off Upvotes and Downvotes make peoples opinions known without flooding threads with effectively the same message over and over again
๐”ˆ๐”ณ๐”ข๐”ฏ ๐”ฆ๐”ซ ๐”ฐ๐”ข๐”ž๐”ฏ๐” ๐”ฅ ๐”ฃ๐”ฌ๐”ฏ ๐”—๐”ฅ๐”ข ๐”๐”ž๐”ฐ๐”ฑ ๐”๐”ข๐”ฉ๐”ฌ๐”ซ
User avatar
skittlesthehusky
Site Admin
Posts: 69
Registered for: 11 months
Contact:

Re: Gotta have Upvotes and Downvotes

Post by skittlesthehusky »

DodoSwarm wrote: Tue Sep 22, 2026 11:26 pm if this forum substitute takes off Upvotes and Downvotes make peoples opinions known without flooding threads with effectively the same message over and over again
it's something that's being discussed with mods! you're right that it allows people to share their opinions without reposting the same messages, but the trade off is that it incentivizes people to simply drop a reaction on the OP instead of replying with a constructive post. some things that votes were also used for on the original forums weren't exactly user friendly (e.g BHVR making it so threads that had -5 in downvotes stopped getting bumped when someone comments) and it left a bad taste in my mouth.

i could maybe add basic reactions to posts, but i don't know if i want to tie a voting system to posts directly just yet. polls are a good option for this if someone wants an opinion voted on, but if it's something that people really want for posts and karma specifically, i can look into it though.
Image
master the art of minding your own business!
----
Fog Dwellers Discord
User avatar
Xaerdys
Member
Posts: 5
Registered for: 1 month

Re: Gotta have Upvotes and Downvotes

Post by Xaerdys »

I'd like to point out, that some people cited the up and downvotes as a reason why the official forum was starving.

I'd vote against the proposal.

Edit: Grammar etc.
now finally with an "s"
User avatar
toga_himiko
Member
Posts: 14
Registered for: 11 days

Re: Gotta have Upvotes and Downvotes

Post by toga_himiko »

I think if there does end up being an upvote/downvote system, it shouldn't affect the visibility of the post

everyone's voice should be heard, even if people don't agree with it !
I loooooooove toga himiko
User avatar
random1543
Member
Posts: 9
Registered for: 1 month

Re: Gotta have Upvotes and Downvotes

Post by random1543 »

I would say reactions would be a good thing, but they should not influence if a post gets bumped or not.

Its one of features I feel is sorely lacking in the official dbd discord.
User avatar
skittlesthehusky
Site Admin
Posts: 69
Registered for: 11 months
Contact:

Re: Gotta have Upvotes and Downvotes

Post by skittlesthehusky »

since this is slowly becoming a more popular request, this is just an official statement that reactions will be added in the coming future. :D
Image
master the art of minding your own business!
----
Fog Dwellers Discord
User avatar
ForTheEntity
Member
Posts: 11
Registered for: 1 month

Re: Gotta have Upvotes and Downvotes

Post by ForTheEntity »

I don't support upvotes and downvotes as they were implemented on the official forum. I think it's part of the reason for the lack of activity on that forum. There were probably many people who came to those forums, posted something, got downvoted and then never posted again. Visible upvotes and downvotes are also part of the reason reddit is so terrible.

I know there is a phpbb feature that allows upvotes but not downvotes. I'd be in favor of that.

If we could have downvotes but not have them shown on the posts but affect post visibility (a downvoted post stops being bumped to the top of the forum with a -5 or worse vote score), I'd be in favor of that.

I doubt this forum is going to get spammed with repetitive suggestions/complaints like the official forums did because on the official forum there was an assumption that BHVR would actually see what you posted. That assumption does not exist here, quite the opposite actually.
User avatar
skittlesthehusky
Site Admin
Posts: 69
Registered for: 11 months
Contact:

Re: Gotta have Upvotes and Downvotes

Post by skittlesthehusky »

the feature has now been implemented and does not affect post visibility. o7
Image
master the art of minding your own business!
----
Fog Dwellers Discord
User avatar
toga_himiko
Member
Posts: 14
Registered for: 11 days

Re: Gotta have Upvotes and Downvotes

Post by toga_himiko »

w skittles
I loooooooove toga himiko