Page 1 of 1

Varying Degrees of Match Commitment

Posted: Fri Oct 02, 2026 8:55 pm
by ForTheEntity
I don't think this topic would be allowed over on the official forums as it might violate their Unsportsmanlike Conduct rule that they very liberally enforce there, but after reviewing the rules here seems fine to talk about here. Honestly I think this is a problem that merits discussion, one that BHVR knowingly or unknowingly chooses to ignore.

Over on the official forum if you've read any amount of posts I am sure you have encountered posters who say if you click Ready (paraphrasing here) you sign a contract written in blood that you will give the match your all until it is over. But there is certainly a different subset of players, a type far less likely to post about it anywhere, who view clicking that Ready button as more like getting a lottery ticket to fun. They're hoping to have fun and if they're not having fun they're ready to move on.

This subset of players play completely different depending on the match they're in. If they are on a map they like vs a killer they like who isn't using perks/strategies they don't like and they're not PWYW in a short killer queue, you probably won't be able to tell the difference between them and a "normal" player. They have no reason to "quit."

But if you put one of these players on a map they don't like, vs a killer they don't like, using strategies/perks they don't like and/or they're PWYW & have a 6 minute killer queue they might "quit." Some players it takes even less like getting downed first or they saw a survivor crouching in a corner for 5 seconds and they "quit." Each player from this subset has a different set of triggers and each trigger could be responded to with varying degrees of "quitting."

The Hard Quit. This is when a quitting survivor is completely done with a match, for whatever reason. Best case scenario is they DC and leave a bot to play in their place. If they want to dodge a DC penalty they might run to the killer to get killed, notification-spam to summon the killer to kill them or just AFK.

The Malicious Quit. This is the worst case scenario, which can happen when it's a team mate that annoys them, and they become malicious. A malicious survivor is the type that tries to hinder a fellow survivor in chase, runs around the map dropping every pallet, sells out teammates, etc. (Another type of player can seem malicious but is just doing whatever it takes to get some annoying challenge done, such as picking up downed survivors in the killer's face with For The People to their own & their team's detriment. Or they might forgo saving a team mate that's 30m away from them in favor of sitting on a gen because they have a complete 10 gens challenge and the game already looks like an L anyway.)

The Soft Quit.
This is probably the most insidious and hard-to-detect "quit." This is when a survivor's heart leaves a match because they have been triggered but for whatever reason don't want to quit, because they don't want a DC penalty or maybe they don't want to completely waste their BPS/anniversary cake offering. They might start the match in this state because they're PWYW & only have a 5 minute killer queue. They might have a particular challenge they're trying to get done and once that's done they don't care anymore. This type of "quit" is also more likely from SoloQ gamers as they can just instantly queue up again once they're out of the match.

They're still playing the game but their heart's not in it, their survival or their team's survival doesn't matter anymore. Similar to triggering each soft quit can be different, depending on the player. The most obvious type is the player who just sits on gens and doesn't care one iota about anything else and the killer can walk right up and grab them off the gen, healthy or not. If they get unhooked they might forgo getting healed and just hop on the nearest gen or totem. If they do run from the killer they give a token chase, just enough of a chase so the killer doesn't think they've given up and slugs them like the last killer did. If put on the hook they often forgo hitting the struggle skill checks. They may be more prone to taking on riskier plays because they don't care about the consequences, because they want to be sent back to the campfire ASAP.

It's the state of "I'm stuck here and I am putting in a token performance" sort of play. I bet all Ghoul mains encounter these soft quitters a lot.

Interestingly the opposite can happen too. A survivor might ready up half-heartedly and then lock-in because they get a particular scenario they love such as against their favorite killer on a favorable map.

The Soft Quit is a very insidious problem because it's very difficult if not impossible to tell the difference between a soft quitter or someone who is new/bad or just having an off match. It's not something BHVR can quantify by looking at their stats. And it's a quiet problem, players don't run around advertising they do this.

Re: Varying Degrees of Match Commitment

Posted: Sat Oct 03, 2026 5:56 am
by skittlesthehusky
a lot of this sort of thing comes from fatigue i've come to realize. players who have subjected themselves enough to the thing that they dislike often end up being ones that check out the most. even worse if they're forced to participate in order to justify their time spent elsewhere in the game (aka. queue times, PWYW when someone may prefer playing killer, etc.)

while i do agree that someone is making the voluntary decision to queue up and should be respectable towards other players' time, i think at some point there also needs to be an acknowledgement that there is indeed a level of burnout that comes with participating in the current game's design. namely, when a player spends a lot of time trying to curate their experience by trying different builds, or practicing something to get better. everything that seems to directly interfere with that experience ends up being much more impactful because their sense of grounding gets taken away.

of course, this sort of emotion towards the experience in itself doesn't come without its own set of reasoning. typically, it can arise from unrealistic expectations or the unwillingness to expand their tastes beyond what they desire. but that's the innate nature of us humans, really. resistance, change, and challenge can invoke negative feelings and disturb a person's comfort whether it's intentional or not. that's where you get your three tiers of quitters as you listed.

sadly this is something that can never be adequately addressed unless direct control is given to specific types or communities of players through means of creating custom experiences. luckily, with the addition of modding and expansive customs options, these same quitters may become less frustrated since now they can go out and find an experience that best suits their interests. this is significantly better than the current matchmaking that forces everybody into one box. people do not have to play with the same energy as others if they really don't want to.

however, the more selfish side of me still wishes that people would just accept the fact that the game, for right now, it's not only just for them. i think the attempts to comfort the disturbed has done a lot more harm than good by encouraging the amount of silent quitters. control was given to players too late. instead it fostered a lot of entitlement and unnecessary frustration that severely impacted matchmaking quality over the years. so much of this could have been prevented if people had ways to avoid burnout beyond not opening the game.

Re: Varying Degrees of Match Commitment

Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2026 11:59 pm
by random1543
Gonna speak honestly here

Speaking of Ghoul, I will play ghoul matches in a "soft quitter" way as you described but I would not call it insidious its hard to MAKE someone put their heart into something.

To explain this is only with ghoul, I will avoid chase like the plague, just focus on the gens, no healing myself just mend and do the gens, if ghoul ends up chasing me make sure chase ends in locker to make slugging less likely, its not fun and im of course not going to put my heart into the chase like I do every other killer when I think the killer has fundamental flaws with his skill floor, until that is addressed I just cant put my heart into looping a ghoul.

On the flip Side tho I will still save and heal my teammates, I will still help the team by being even more aggressive in taking hits and bodyblocks. pre STB nerfs I would use it aggressively in ghoul matches because I didn't care if I had more hook-states.

I personally just have no interest in ghoul matches at all but I know community has a issue with DCers so i just play with minimal effort in the chase department most of time more focused on avoiding chase, pumping gens, and helping teammates the parts of game where I do not have to interact with ghoul.

Other killers I find unfun but wont find myself doing this, Ghoul is just such a drain to verse for me I took a break from game months after he came out till spring-trap but still hes Top pick killer in my region since he has came out at least since last stats we got Oceania top pick is ghoul. x.x

Slight off topic but this is why I wish a killer pick could be blocked, eg if im ready up in soloq I can pick 1 killer to choice to avoid. SWF would not get 4 and would still only be able to avoid 1.

Re: Varying Degrees of Match Commitment

Posted: Fri Oct 09, 2026 8:24 pm
by Xaerdys
I have no specific killer. I always try my best. But there a days where IU get tunneled 5 matches in a row. Makes it hard to stay motivated, so can kinda understand if people are not too engaged sometimes. Sometimes people have bad day and you are just the match they need for that one daily quest.